Marble vs alabaster lighting: what the difference actually looks like

Alabaster lets light through, so the whole stone glows when it's switched on. Marble mostly holds light back. Here's what that means for choosing a light, caring for it and telling the real stone from an imitation.

By Owen Pryce, YUBI Home · Updated 10 November 2026

Alabaster lets light through, and marble mostly holds it back. Switch on an alabaster light and the stone itself glows, veins and all. Marble glows only faintly, so its light comes out through an opening, a shade or glass.

Below: what each stone is, why only one of them glows, how to look after each, and how to tell real alabaster from an imitation.

What are alabaster and marble made of?

Marble is a metamorphic rock, which means heat and pressure underground have changed it. Carbonate minerals, most often calcite, recrystallise into a dense stone. Because calcite is a carbonate, acids attack it, which is why vinegar and other acidic cleaners are kept away from marble.

"Alabaster" is the name for two different stones. Gypsum alabaster is a fine-grained form of gypsum, a hydrous calcium sulphate. It's soft: 1.5 to 2 on the Mohs scale of mineral hardness, so a fingernail scratches it. Calcite alabaster is a banded form of calcite, the same mineral that makes up most marble, and at 3 on the Mohs scale it resists a fingernail but not a knife.

Both kinds of alabaster are easy to carve and slightly soluble in water. That second fact matters later, when it comes to care.

Why does alabaster glow when marble doesn't?

Because of how far light gets into the stone. Alabaster is translucent: cut into thin sheets, it lets enough light through to have been used for small windows. Put a bulb behind it and the whole piece lights up, with the veining showing as darker drifts through the glow.

Our Colette Wall Light shows the alabaster side of this. The stone glows through its cloudy veining while a soft wash of light spreads up and down the wall, so a single fitting draws a column of light rather than a hard spot.

Marble isn't completely opaque either. Light gets about 13 to 38mm into calcite before it scatters, which is what gives a marble sculpture its soft, waxy surface. It can even pass daylight when it's cut thin: the Beinecke Library at Yale is walled with marble panels 32mm thick, and daylight comes through them as an amber glow. That takes full daylight on thin panels, though. In a lamp, marble usually frames the light rather than carrying it.

Our Ophelia Pendant Light shows the marble side. Its light spills from a slot in the veined marble and from a frosted tube beneath it, so the stone frames the glow rather than carrying it.

What does the difference look like in a room?

Alabaster Marble
What it is Gypsum (calcium sulphate) or banded calcite Recrystallised carbonate rock, mostly calcite
Hardness 1.5–2 (gypsum) or 3 (calcite) on the Mohs scale: a fingernail marks gypsum alabaster About 3, like calcite: a knife marks it, a fingernail doesn't
With the light on The stone glows from inside, and the veins show dark through it The stone stays mostly solid, and the light comes from an opening, a shade or glass
Where you'll usually see it in a light Shades, wall lights and diffusers Bases, and shades with an opening
Its weak point Water and steam Acids, which etch it

Which is why alabaster tends to be the part of a light you look at when it's on, and marble the part you look at when it's off.

The Ines Table Lamp uses marble the way it works best. Its rounded base is deep red marble with white veining, cool and smooth to the touch. Above it, a cone shade throws the light down across the table and gently up the wall. The stone is there to be seen and touched; the shade does the lighting.

Is alabaster more fragile than marble?

Yes, in two ways. Gypsum alabaster is soft enough to scratch with a fingernail, so a ring or a key will mark it. And alabaster is slightly soluble in water, which is why it isn't used outdoors, and why care guides say to keep it away from steam and direct moisture.

Marble's weak point is acid. An acid doesn't stain marble so much as dissolve a very thin layer of it, leaving a dull patch called an etch. On a lamp base that's rarely an issue unless something gets spilled; it's the reason to wipe a splash straight away rather than leave it.

This is general guidance for each stone:

Do Avoid
Both stones Switch the light off, then dust with a soft, dry microfibre cloth Scrubbing, abrasive cleaners, solvents and anything acidic
Alabaster Keep it dry. Brass parts can take a slightly damp cloth Water on the stone, steam, bathrooms, and long spells of direct sunlight, which can discolour it
Marble Wipe splashes straight away. A natural detergent and a soft brush once a month Vinegar, lemon and other acids

How can you tell real alabaster from an imitation?

Start with the material line on the product page. A word like "alabaster-effect" or "stone-look" means it isn't the stone. The reverse trick exists too: alabaster can be heat-treated to make it opaque, so that it looks like marble. The material line is the only reliable answer, so if it's vague, ask.

Then switch it on. Real alabaster is translucent, and its veining shows as darker lines and clouds through the light. A perfectly even glow with no veining at all points to resin or frosted glass.

Pick it up if you can. Stone is heavy for its size: Colette's page lists it at 2,800g for a light 34cm tall. A "stone" shade that feels light in the hand is worth a question.

Leave the scratch test alone. A fingernail does mark gypsum alabaster, which is exactly why you shouldn't try it on a light you want to keep.

Which should you choose?

Choose alabaster where you want the stone itself to be the light: a wall light beside a bed or an armchair, or a shade you'll look at every evening. Choose marble where you want the stone seen by day and the light sent where it's needed, as in a lamp base or a shade with an opening.

At the moment our alabaster is on the wall, in Colette; any stone in our pendants and table lamps is marble.

The one habit that matters most is keeping alabaster dry. With that in mind, look through our lighting and check the material line on each page before you choose.

Questions people ask

Is alabaster a type of marble?

No. Marble is a recrystallised carbonate rock, usually calcite. Alabaster is one of two other stones: gypsum alabaster, a soft calcium sulphate, or calcite alabaster, which shares marble's main mineral but is a different stone. The difference you can see is in the light: alabaster lets it through, and marble mostly holds it back.

Can you put an alabaster light in a bathroom?

It's better not to. Alabaster is porous and slightly soluble in water, and care guides say to keep it away from steam and direct moisture. In a bathroom, choose a light made for bathrooms instead, and keep alabaster for a bedroom, a hallway or a living room, where the air stays dry.

Does alabaster change colour over time?

It can if it sits in strong sun for long periods. Care guides advise keeping alabaster out of prolonged direct sunlight to prevent discolouration. A wall light on a wall the sun doesn't reach, or a lamp away from a sunny window, avoids the problem. Dust it with a dry cloth rather than wiping it with water.

Can marble glow like alabaster?

Only faintly, and only when it's cut thin with strong light behind it. Light gets a few centimetres into marble before it scatters, which gives it a soft, waxy look. A solid base or a thick shade won't carry a bulb's light through, so marble lights let it out through an opening, a shade or glass.

Owen writes YUBI Home's material guides: stoneware, glaze, marble, alabaster, glass and brass, and what each one means for the piece on your table. Owen is a YUBI Home house byline. Every piece is researched with AI tools and edited by Max, our founder.